Creamy Polenta Roasted Mushrooms

There's something almost meditative about standing over a pot of polenta, watching it transform from grainy liquid into something silky and luxurious. I discovered this dish on a quiet autumn evening when I had a handful of mushrooms and nothing else seemed appealing, and now it's become my go-to when I want something that feels both fancy and deeply comforting. The first time I nailed the consistency, I understood why Italian nonnas have been making this for centuries—it's simple, but it rewards attention. That night, the smell of garlic and thyme roasting in the oven while the polenta bubbled away made my whole kitchen feel like home.

I made this for friends on a Friday night when the weather turned cold, and watching them scrape their bowls clean told me everything I needed to know. One of them asked if it was restaurant food, and I realized that's exactly what it feels like to eat, even though you made it yourself in about an hour. The golden mushrooms piled on top catch the light, and somehow that simple arrangement makes it look elegant without trying.

Ingredients

• Coarse cornmeal (polenta): The texture matters here—coarse cornmeal cooks into something silky instead of lumpy, and it actually tastes like corn. Don't grab the fine flour by mistake.
• Water and milk: The combination gives you richness without overwhelming the delicate corn flavor; use whole milk if you can, it makes a difference.
• Unsalted butter and Parmesan: These are the secret layers of flavor—the butter melts through to coat every grain, and the cheese adds a sharp note that keeps everything balanced.
• Kosher salt and black pepper: Season as you stir; polenta soaks up salt differently as it cooks, so taste and adjust near the end.
• Mixed mushrooms: Use whatever looks good at the market—cremini, shiitake, and oyster together give you different textures and earthy depth.
• Olive oil and garlic: These roast together and become sweet and golden, coating each mushroom piece.
• Fresh thyme: It perfumes the whole pan while roasting and pairs perfectly with mushrooms in a way dried thyme just doesn't quite reach.
• Fresh parsley: This is your last-minute brightness, the thing that reminds you this dish is alive and not heavy.

Instructions

Heat your oven and prepare the mushrooms:

Preheat to 425°F while you slice your mushrooms into pieces roughly the same size so they roast evenly. Toss them on a baking sheet with olive oil, minced garlic, thyme, salt, and pepper—get them in a single layer so they have room to brown instead of steam.

Roast until golden:

Let them go for 20 to 25 minutes, stirring once halfway through so they brown all over. You'll know they're ready when the edges are caramelized and they smell almost sweet.

Start the polenta base:

While mushrooms roast, bring water and milk to a rolling boil in a large saucepan and add your salt. This is the foundation—good heat now means smooth polenta later.

Whisk in the cornmeal slowly:

This is where people get nervous, but there's no magic to it. Lower your heat to medium and whisk the cornmeal in slowly, a little at a time, so it doesn't clump. Once it's all in, turn the heat all the way down to low.

Stir constantly until creamy:

Now comes the meditative part—stir for 20 to 25 minutes, scraping the bottom and sides of the pan frequently. The polenta will go from thin and loose to thick and creamy, and it'll start pulling away from the sides of the pan slightly when it's ready.

Finish with richness:

Remove from heat and stir in butter, Parmesan, and a few grinds of black pepper. Taste it and adjust seasoning—this is your moment to make it exactly right.

Serve warm and top:

Spoon polenta into bowls while it's still warm, pile those roasted mushrooms on top, scatter parsley over everything, and add an extra handful of Parmesan if you're feeling generous.

Pin It

The moment when you plate this—when the warm, butter-yellow polenta hits the bowl and you top it with those jeweled mushrooms—feels like you've done something small and lovely. It's the kind of dish that makes you realize how good simple food can taste when you pay attention to it.

Why This Becomes a Regular

This dish lands somewhere between weeknight dinner and something you'd serve at a dinner party, which is exactly where the best recipes live. You can make it in under an hour, which means it fits into a real life, and the ingredient list is short enough that you probably have half of it already. The beauty of it is that it tastes fancy and feels nourishing without any fussing.

Variations and Extensions

Once you have the basic polenta down, it becomes a base for so many things. You can roast different vegetables—try tomatoes with basil, or broccoli with garlic—or make it vegan by using plant-based butter and nutritional yeast in place of Parmesan. Some nights, I drizzle a little truffle oil over the top right before serving, which transforms it into something almost decadent with just a few drops.

Building Your Own Version

The real power of this recipe is that once you understand how polenta works, you can build it the way you want. The ratio of liquid to cornmeal is what matters most, and everything else is just flavor and texture that you can adjust to what you have and what you're craving. Some cooks prefer a thinner polenta you pour into bowls, while others like it thick enough to set on a baking sheet and slice—both are right, and both are delicious in different ways.

• If you want thinner polenta, use a bit more liquid and cook it slightly less; if you want it thicker for slicing, reduce the liquid slightly and let it get a little firmer.
• Mushrooms vary wildly in water content, so your roasting time might shift by a few minutes depending on what you bought and how you sliced them.
• This is best eaten right when it comes together, so time it so the polenta and mushrooms finish around the same moment.

Pin It

This is the kind of recipe that makes you feel like a good cook, which is half the pleasure of cooking it. Make it once and it becomes yours.

Recipe Questions

→ What type of cornmeal is best for the polenta?

Coarse cornmeal yields a creamier, traditional texture for this dish. Fine cornmeal can result in a less substantial consistency.

→ How do I ensure the mushrooms roast perfectly?

Toss mushrooms evenly with olive oil, garlic, thyme, salt, and pepper, then roast at a high temperature (425°F) until golden and tender, stirring once midway.

→ Can I substitute Parmesan cheese?

For dairy-free options, nutritional yeast or vegan cheese alternatives offer a similar savory flavor without altering texture significantly.

→ Is this dish suitable for gluten-free diets?

Yes, polenta is naturally gluten-free, but ensure all ingredients, especially cornmeal and cheese, are certified gluten-free to avoid contamination.

→ What sides pair well with this dish?

A crisp green salad or grilled vegetables balance the creamy polenta and add fresh texture to the meal.